There are few Clean Tech companies I am very interested in. Energy Resources (ERII) and PWR are obviously some of these companies, but the rest are private. For instance, there is Gridpoint (that will be key for Smartgrid deployment) and A123 Systems (that has some really interesting battery technology). One of these have now filed to go public under ‘AONE’… (i just keep thinking of the steak sauce
).
I follow this company closey because I truly believe America will be shifting from a carbon base economy to an electric base society. While closely following them, I was itching to take a look at their financials and now we are all able to. After taking a look, I have to say, I was disappointed.
IMO, their financials suck. Their ‘cost of product revenue’ is higher then their ‘product revenue’, but what concerns me the most is that the rate of cost growth is higher than revenue from 2006 to 2007. Then the Percent of costs (in relation to revenue) in the 1st 3 months of the year is way too high.

The company explains this in their registration by the statement below:
“We incur costs associated with unabsorbed manufacturing expenses prior to a factory being qualified for commercial production. We expect these unabsorbed manufacturing costs, which include certain personnel, rent, utilities, materials, testing and depreciation costs, to increase in absolute dollars and as a percentage of revenue in the near term, and we expect these costs to decrease as a percentage of revenue as a result of higher revenue.”
A123 will see much higher revenue growth. They will start mass producing for car companies (Chevy Volt, Think), and has seen HUGE general demand. IMO, they will also play a big role in storage capacity for Wind and Solar farms. Not to mention the conventional uses of their batteries. So for A123 to really succeed they will need to keep ‘cost of product revenue’ fairly constant (or grow much slower) while revenue grows quickly.
The question now becomes, ‘at what price are we willing to pay for this Revenue growth?’ The stock does not only have to perform well selling products, but also control costs and become profitable. The cost of revenue figure is simply not encouraging at all. There is no sense of margin expectation. A123 System’s technology is really interesting that should command higher margins, so where are these margins?
Another negative is that this company is seeing a lot of press. More so then I thought it would see. I fear its IPO will be distrubingly high, causing the stock price to be too high.
Some of the figures they toute in the regristration with respect to macro-economic environment seem way too conserative. To give a sense of the potential in energy storage see this article.
I can go on and on, and if I were paid to do this type of analysis I would be more specific comparing management’s figures with estimates that I have seen over the past few months, but I have to start packing to go on holiday.
I like the long-term story with A123 a lot, but not a fan of the near-term financials. So I have to wait and see how it trades, and expect to purchase the stock on a premium only because of the macro economic wind pushing on its back.